Eli Manning vs. Kurt Warner

It's hard to throw a rookie quarterback in as an immediate starter, no matter how talented. That's why the Giants signed Warner, a two-time MVP who wants to show the world he can still play after the Rams gave up on him. Manning will someday be a heck of a quarterback, but it might take time. He's smart and instinctive, but this is the NFL, not the SEC. Warner gives the Giants a chance to ease Manning in, maybe this year but likely late in the season. But, what happens if Warner plays so well Manning can't get on the field? Did the Giants do the right thing in acquiring him? Or should they taken their lumps and let Manning play this year? Tough call.

posted by Anonymous @ 2:30 PM

|

---